Back on Broadway
Musicals and Dramas
By: Jay Handelman - Nov 20, 2026
Everytime I return to New York City for a few days of theatergoing, it’s like visiting a familiar old friend who has new stories to share.
My annual fall trip for a stimulating American Theatre Critics/Journalists Association conference, left me time to see seven shows. Two of them – the new musical “The Heart” and the drama “Downstate” – were as stimulating and involving as anything I’ve seen in several years. The others, including the Broadway debut of the long-running off-Broadway classic “The Fantasticks” and the Tony Award-winning “Schmigadoon,” also have much to recommend.
These productions featured at least three actors who have performed on Sarasota area stages in the last few years.
Here’s a look at what you can see on Broadway, and off, this fall, presented in the order in which I experienced them, ending with the week’s highlight.
“The Lost Boys: A New Musical”
“The Lost Boys: A New Musical,” based on the 1987 film about a group of vampires that have taken over a California beach town, is a technical wonder. The vampires fly with almost no wires visible through the moody lighting by Jen Schriever and director Michael Arden. Dane Laffrey’s sets do almost the same thing, dropping from the rafters, or rising from beneath the stage. The actors are committed, with powerful voices that bring an edge to the music and lyrics by The Rescues.
What’s missing is heart, a suprise from Arden, who has previously staged such emotionally involving shows as “Parade” and “Maybe Happy Ending.”
I never saw the film, so I was curious about how teenager Michael Emerson might avoid a full transformation into a vampire after he befriends the members of a punkish band that plays on the Santa Carla boardwalk. Michael wants to impress the attractive young singer Star, who is in her own kind of limbo as a half-vampire.
In transforming the movie to the stage, writers David Hornsby and Chris Hoch have a little fun with the storytelling, making jokes about the absurdity of turning movies into musicals, but they haven’t found a way to make you really care about the characters.
I did care about Star, played by Maria Wirries, who grew up performing in Sarasota. She has grown into a dynamic performer who, lke others in the cast, overcomes weaknesses in the script to perform with passion and yearning.
I did enjoy watching LJ Benet in his Broadway debut as Michael; Tony-winner Soshana Bean as a mother trying to move forward; Benjamin Pajak as Michael’s younger brother who becomes a vampire hunter; and Tony-winner Ali Louis Bourzgi as the vampire band leader. The cast also includes Paul Alexander Nolan as a video store owner and a father far different from the one he played in “Knoxville” at Asolo Repertory Theatre.
“The Lost Boys” is running at the Palace Theatre, 160 W. 47th St., New York. lostboysmusical.com
“Schmigadoon”
I loved Cinco Paul’s Apple TV series “Schmigadoon((,))” a loving and satirical ode to the glory days of musical theater in the mid((-))20th century, but I had my doubts it would work as a Broadway show. It certainly does.
Directed and choreographed by Christopher Gattelli, it’s a cotton candy-colored version of the series’ first season, filled with humor, romantic twists and a winning cast who maximize the laughs. It’s silly and pure fun.
The songs intentionally evoke classics from such shows as “Oklahoma” and “Brigadoon,” but the songwriter plays around with them musically and lyrically.
The story is about Josh Skinner and Melissa Gimble, two busy doctors trying to mend the tension that has built up between them. On a couples retreat, they wind up in a seemingly mythical town called Schmigadoon (think “Brigadoon”) where almost every line is a song cue. (And Josh hates muicals.) Scott Pask’s set looks like it emerged from “The Music Man” by way of Disneyland’s Main Street USA, a view of a perfect Americana.
Sara Chase as Melissa and Alex Brightman as Josh are a delight to watch as they try to find a way back to loving each other. At a cafe, Melissa asks about corn pudding that leads to a major dance routine. Josh just wants to disappear. Later, while half-heartedly working at a school, Josh inadvertently triggers another rousing dance, encouraging him to do his job “With All Your Heart.”
While the show is kind of a fantasy, Gattelli and his cast ground it with comically human performances. Jennifer Simard is a riot as the hellfire and brimstone-spouting wife of the local minister, biting into each worrisome word in “Tribulation,” an ode to “Trouble” from “Music Man.” (Simard will be replaced Dec. 4 by “Ru Paul’s Drag Race” judge Michelle Visage.) The supporting cast is equally impressive, and the ensemble performs with pep and big smiles to remind you of the good old days of musical comedy.
“Schmigadoon” runs through April 4 at the Nederlander Theatre, 208 W. 41st St., New York. schmigadoononbroadway.com
“The Fantasticks”
Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt’s “The Fantasticks,” the world’s longest-running musical, is such a perennial favorite that it is truly part of our lives. But I’ve never been the biggest fan of the show, resistant to its sweet but convoluted romantic charms that have clearly impressed millions of others since it opened off-Broadway in 1960.
The musical, which ran for 42 years at the tiny Sullivan Street Theatre, has just made its Broadway debut in a production that may have finally worn down my resistance.
Before his death in 2023, playwright and lyricist Tom Jones made some minor but significant changes. In the original, two fathers plot to bring together their lovelorn son and daughter by pretending to feud and keep them apart. After all, kids always do what they’re told not to.
Matt and Louise are now Matt and Lewis, two boys who are just as much in love. But they have a lot of learning to do before the world lets them explore happiness together. The fathers have become doting mothers, a smart decision.
It somehow makes the story even more universal and contemporary. And while the second act is still a little clunky as the lovers (and mothers) try to move past happily ever after, this version won me over.
Maybe it’s the fact that amid lots of shows with major stars, big singing and even bigger production designs, “The Fantasticks” favors theatrical simplicity – a casrdboard (( moon here or some a trunk of props there. It’s almost the anti-Broadway musical.
The Second Stage Theatre production stars Maxim Chlumecky (who was recently Fyedka in Asolo Rep’s “Fiddler on the Roof”) as Matt and Nathan Levy as Lewis. They’re both young, attractive and appealing. Their mothers are played by the delightful pairing of Ruthie Ann Miles and Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer, who plot together, love their children, and then go through their own squabbles when the hoped-for happy ending takes a darker turn.
That darkness is overseen by Zane Phillips as the narrator El Gallo, who is hired by the mothers to stage an abduction to test their children’s devotion to one another. He’s a big, muscular and physically commanding presence, with a wicked grin and flirtatious charm that appears to work, in different ways, on all the characters.
They are joined David Patrick Kelly as The Old Actor and Kevin Del Aguila, as Mortimer (The Man Who Dies), an often hilarious duo of overstated acting, and Ahmad Simmons as The Mute, who moves with grace while standing to represent a wall that keeps the kids apart, holding a moon or skipping around to keep the story moving.
Christopher Gatelli, who is better known for big splashy musicals like “Schmigadoon” and the recently departed “Death Becomes Her,” brings a loving touch to this production. Though it has been produced in countless regional, community and high school productions, this new version feels wonderfully fresh on Broadway.
“The Fanatasticks,” presented by Second Stage Theatre, runs through Feb. 7 at the Hayes Theatre, 240 W. 44th St., New York. 2st.com; fantasticksbroadway.com
”Downstate”
Bruce Norris’ powerful and disturbing play “Downstate” provided a perfect reminder of what I love about live theater. There were numerous scenes in Joe Mantello’s production that were so compelling and involving that I forgot that I was watching a play. They were so earnest and believable that I frequently felt they were happening right in real life.
Norris likes to provoke, as he showed in his earlier play “Clybourne Park,” and “Downstate” will trigger strong reactions. It is about four sexual predators living together in a group home in Illinois, and begins on the day when one of their victims shows up seeking an admission of guilt from his attacker.
The subject is clearly not for everyone. Norris does attempt to humanize the men in small degrees, while raising questions about the memories of both the perpetrators and the victims. It offers stark reminders of the legal limits placed on the men in their every day lives.
The play begins with Thomas Sadoski as Andy, who was abused by his piano teacher 30 years ago, confronting his much older and wheelchair bound former teacher, demanding an admission of guilt. As played brilliantly by Francis Guinan,
Fred is calm, friendly and even encouraging to Andy, a sign of the ways he may have seduced him years earlier.
Sadoski has a couple of really emotional scenes that become explosive as we learn more about his character and the problems he faced at home as a child that may have led him to lean on Fred. Maybe, Fred’s roommate Dee wonders, things didn’t happen quite the way Andy remembers them.
Dee, played by the impressive K. Todd Freeman, is a proud gay man who defends his years-long relationship with a 14-year-old boy while they were performing in a tour of “Peter Pan.” Dee claims it was consensual. Others see it as statutory rape. Norris and Freeman make you kind of like him and hate him at the same time.
Al’Jaleel McGhee, who starred in “Paradise Blue” earlier this year at Westcoast Black Theatre Troupe, plays the go-getter Gio, with a million ideas for starting a new business, and Adrian Martinez is moving as the Bible-clutching and despondent Felix, who is desperate to contact his daughter and see his ill sister.
Liza Colón-Zayas, an Emmy winner for the TV series “The Bear,” is appropriately no-nonsense as their probation officer, who tries to keep them in check. Ivy Wolk is a provocative live wire as Gio’s co-worker and Cassie Beck has a couple of brief scenes as Andy’s supportive and seemingly frustrated wife.
Disturbing and shocking as it can be, the play is one of the most compelling I’ve seen in years.
“Downstate” has been extended through Feb. 14 at the Booth Theatre, 222 W. 45th St., New York. downstateonbroadway.com
“Wanted”
Powerhouse singing is the main calling card of the new musical “Wanted.” If you want a clear-eyed story, you may have to look elsewhere.
It is set in 1890s Texas where twin sisters Mary and Martha Clarke set out to make the money they need to help their mother buy the land she is owed after picking cotton on it for years. The sisters have little trouble passing as white, but rather than using more reasonable methods, they quickly realize they can make more money by robbing rich white people.
The play features a book and lyrics by Angelica Cheri, the great-great niece of the real-life sisters. The production claims the story is “mostly true,” but how much is folklore or exaggerated legend is not clear.
Through the performances of Solea Pfeiffer as Mary and Liisi LaFontaine as Martha, you really want them to succeed. You may also feel a little cringy about some of the twists the story takes. Mary loses sight of the goal when she falls in love with the wealthy white businessman Jesse (Bradley Jaden), even willing to risk revealing her true identity by marrying him. The more determined Martha rebels and plots some retribution to make up for their mother’s humiliations. She also has a flirtation that doesn’t go anywhere with Luke James as Jesse’s right-hand-man,
You do care about them up to a point in the production staged by Stevie Walker-Webb and choreographed by Chelsey Arce. You also feel for their mother, usually played by the singer and songwriter Ledisi, but replaced at a recent performance by her thrilling understudy Jennie Harney-Fleming. She’s a proud mother who has instilled a strong spirit in her daughters that will be tested as they set off on their own.
All three have stunning voices, but they’re often overwhelmed by the stirring ensemble cast of Kinfolks, who beautifully wail with voices that burst through the rafters. It can feel like you’re going to church, and the wood barn-like set designed by Beowulf Boritt adds to that feeling. And it is hard not to fall for Awa Sal Secka and Aurelia Williams, who offer a lot of humor and heart as two of Jesse’s hotel employees.
The music by Ross Baum, in his Broadway debut, is melodic and often catchy, if not memorable. The story starts meandering midway through the show, which dilutes the importance of its ultimate message of the importance of freedom and self-determination.
“Wanted” is playing at the James Earl Jones Theatre, 138 W. 48th St., New York. wantedmusical.com
“The Curious Case of Benjamin Button”
Time is of the essence in Jethro Compton’s musical adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s quirky short story “The Curious Case of Benjamin Button,” about a man who is born at the age of 70 and gets younger every day.
Compton wrote the book and co-wrote the lyrics with composer Darren Clark. He also directs this lively, Celtic-flavored show, which shares Benjamin’s story as a kind of folk tale passed on and embellished across the years by the people from his small fishing village.
He uses the title and basic premise, but Compton shifts the locale from Baltimore to Cornwall and begins the story in 1918 rather than the original story’s 1860. The new timeline allows Benjamin to be among the troops landing in Normandy during World War II, and to watch with growing fascination the race to the moon. He spends years working on a fishing boat and takes on other jobs.
It’s fun to watch, though many of the more rousing Celtic melodies, played and sung by a hard-working and diverse cast of actor-singer-musicians, begin to sound somewhat the same, even when they’re interspersed with a tender ballad or shanty-like number. It also becomes tiresome to hear cast members reference specific times in Benjamin’s life, such as his being born at 17 minutes past 8 p.m. on the 17th of December 1918.
Benjamin is played by the versatile Andrew Durand, who accomplishes the reverse-aging process without any makeup or change of costumes. He uses a cane at birth but grows sturdier, more upright, energetic and athletic as he gets younger. He is shy but determined to find his place, and he has patience as he pursues a bar maid named Elowen (a charming Kelsee Kimmel) for months, despite saying little more than “a pint” and “thank you.” She is smitten from the start.
They are surrounded by a cast that plays fiddles, violins, guitars, accordion, percussion and more, occasionally stepping away from their instruments to portray Benjamin’s parents, children, a drunken baker and others.
It’s tuneful and fast-moving while it shares lessons about making the most of the time you have. But the telling also grows wearying as it drifts toward a finale with little impact.
“The Curious Case of Benjamin Button” runs through Dec. 20 at The Public Theater’s Newman Theatre, 425 Lafayette St., New York. publictheater.org
“The Heart”
A description of the beautiful new musical “The Heart” might not sound appealing, but don’t hesitate. It is moving, funny, crushing and enveloping, and I fell in love with it not long after the opening number.
It’s essentially about the steps involved in a heart transplant and all the people involved in saving organs to help others live. But it is far more than a fact-based documentary.
Based on the French novel “Réparer les Vivants” by Maylis de Kerangal, it introduces us to a 19-year-old surfer who is left brain dead after a car accident. In short order, we meet his divorced and battling parents who struggle to let the hospital share his organs; the emergency room doctor and nurse who treat him with varying levels of personal care; the organ procurement coordinator who makes sure that he is treated respectfully at every step; the surfer’s DJ girlfriend; and a 50-year-old woman who, after waiting three years of waiting, is ready to die when she gets the call about a match.
Each of the characters is sensitively and humorously depicted in the production staged by Christopher Ashley, the new artistic director of Roundabout Theatre Company. (He brought the show with him from his previous job at the La Jolla Playhouse.)
I had tears in my eyes at times during the smallest moments – such as when the girlfriend, Juliet, passed a recording of the waves for the doctors to play during the surgery, or watching the parents struggle to accept their son’s death. The tears later flowed while Heidi Blickenstaff, as the recipient Claire, sang about the possibility of her own new life while mourning the death of someone “Too Young.”
It may sound maudlin, but it’s really inspiring.
Ashley, scenic designer Robert Brill, sound designer Gareth Owen and video designer Lucy Mackinnon create the sensations of a constant thump thump of a beating heart, on a stage that shifts from the beach to an operating room and more with the movement of a table and some hospital equipment and impactful projections.
Kait Kerrigan, also represented on Broadway by “The Great Gatsby,” wrote the book and additional lyrics to the electronic score and arrangements by Anne and Ian Eisendrath. It pulsates with rhythms that might inspire a rave or remind you that you’re still alive and breathing. There are some crushing melodies. Joaquina Kalukango, as the mother, powerfully hits all the emotions in her solo “Marianne’s Dream” and partners nicely with Jason Tam as her ex in “Quicksand.”
The cast also includes Lincoln Clauss, who so memorably portrayed the Emcee in “Cabaret” at Asolo Repertory Theatre a few years ago, as the efficient procurement officer.
There is a lot of talk about this show possibly moving to Broadway. It might be an underdog in such a hot commercial environment where shows need big stars to survive. But this one has such a big heart and great word of mouth, it just might survive and and keep beating. I’d see it again in a minute.
“The Heart” runs through Dec. 13 at the Roundabout Theatre Company’s Laura Pels Theatre at the Harold and Miriam Steinberg Center for Theatre, 111 W. 46th St., New York. roundabouttheatre.org
To learn more and donate visit ArtsBeat.org.